Providing Divorce Mediation Services Throughout California
Providing Divorce Mediation Services Throughout California

Divorce Mediation vs Collaborative Divorce: Key Differences

You may have heard of divorce mediation from a friend TV, or the San Jose community.

Collaborative Divorce vs Mediation in CA – Which’s Best?

Contents

Need an Experienced Mediator?

Reach out to find the best solution for your divorce with trusted professionals.

Divorce Mediation vs Collaborative Divorce: Key Differences & The Best Route

In California, divorce mediation and collaborative practice are two ways to settle matters; both have their own feel. Mediation typically feels more informal, less costly, and faster, often with a neutral mediator providing guidance for the discussion, solutions and filing of the agreements and court forms, including the divorce or legal separation judgment.

Collaborative divorce is similar to traditional divorce as the process is more structured, and the lawyers are leading the discussions. It is also typically more costly and slower than mediation. The end result for collaboration is to also reach a fully filed divorce or legal separation judgment.

In simple words, divorce mediation is more effective when both partners can reasonably communicate, and collaborative divorce is best for couples who desire more involvement from the legal system. If you want an easier, simpler and less costly divorce experience, try Divorce mediation with Dina Haddad, California’s expert attorney-mediator. Book your FREE DIVORCE MEDIATION Consult now!

Divorce Mediation in California

Divorce mediation in California is where both spouses work together with a neutral third party to come to an agreement, mostly out of court. It is based on private mediation, which is confidential, flexible, and the lowest-cost option when using attorneys.

Mediation differs from traditional litigation in several ways: it involves no public hearings, less formality, and a more relaxed process, with the couple in control. 

Mediation differs from collaborative divorce in that the couple is not required to have a team of professionals or separate attorneys representing either party.

How it Works

First, both spouses agree to mediation. The mediator, a family law professional, describes the process, collects information from each party privately, and helps identify your worries, priorities, and questions about the next steps.

One of the biggest benefits of divorce mediation is that meetings can have flexible schedules and sometimes be online. The mediator facilitates the discussion, urges compliance and uses one of the mediator’s activities to finally draft an agreement. 

Once you reach an agreement, it’s written in a marital settlement document, reviewed by attorneys, and filed with the court to turn it into a judgment.

Collaborative Divorce in California

In a collaborative divorce, both spouses hire a specially trained attorney who is dedicated to resolving the case outside of court. Both spouses will enter into an agreement that neither will litigate (go to court on any issue). 

Collaborative divorce usually involves other professionals in the process, including financial advisors or child specialists.Collaborative divorce is more formal and expensive than private mediation; however, it still has a similar focus on resolving the issues privately and reducing hostility. 

The process works similarly to mediation, except the collaborative divorce process may feel more attorney-driven than spouse-driven.

Key features

How Collaborative Divorce Works in CA?

Once both spouses agree to work collaboratively, each has their own lawyer. The first meetings are to identify the issues, goals and documents needed. After this phase, joint meetings happen with lawyers and possibly other experts if needed.

Everyone will try to come to a settlement that is acceptable to both sides. If collaboration fails, the collaborative lawyers will withdraw from the case, and new lawyers will continue the divorce litigation.

When Comparing Divorce Mediation with Collaborative, We Find These 9 Striking Differences Between Them.

Before we go into detailed comparative analysis of divorce mediation between collaborative practice in California. Here’s a quick, tabular comparison between these two divorcing routes: 

Aspects
Divorce Mediation
Collaborative Divorce
Cost
Lower overall fees.
Higher due to multiple professionals.
Time
Usually quicker resolution.
Often a longer process.
Conflict Level
Cooperative tone.
Lawyer-led discussions.
Formality
Informal, flexible sessions.
Structured, formal meetings.
Final Outcome
Mutually crafted agreement.
Agreement shaped by legal team.
Representation
Optional, consult as needed.
Required from the start.

1. Cost

Mediation in California typically costs between a few thousand and fifteen thousand dollars, depending on the complexity. Collaborative divorce might cost even more, as you are hiring two attorneys, and sometimes other professionals as well.

2. Time Required to Complete Divorce

Mediation can last a few months, usually three to six. Collaborative divorce usually lasts longer, up to eight to fourteen months, because there are more people to coordinate.

3. Conflict Level

Mediation encourages cooperation, especially when communication is alive. Collaborative divorce may feel more tense; even though you all want the same outcome, you are still represented by lawyers, so there is some aspect of the adversary remaining.

4. Formality

Mediation, especially online divorce mediation, is more casual, and less constricted by court rules. Collaborative divorce is a more structured approach, where parties sign a formal agreement, utilize professionals for support, and adhere to strict rules.

5. Divorce Mediator vs Collaborative Divorce Lawyer

In mediation, you have one neutral mediator. In collaborative divorce, you have two lawyers—plus often a financial neutral and a parenting coach. It becomes more of a team exercise than a discussion.

6. Legal Representation

Mediation doesn’t have to involve lawyers, although people frequently turn to them. Collaborative means the parties have a lawyer before the process starts, which means the process leans more toward getting legal advice along the way.

7. Decision Making and Final Outcome

In mediation, you will make final decisions together with the help of the mediator. In collaborative divorce, you will still make decisions, but within a more formal legal process, with professionals to help guide you along.

8.Non-Adversarial Resolution

Both are seeking to keep the process less adversarial. Mediation feels less adversarial, but collaborative may lose some of that collaborative feeling. Because attorneys are in the room, it feels more like a legal negotiation.

9.Neutrality

Mediation brings in a neutral third party who cares only about helping both. Collaborative involves advocates who represent each spouse, so neutrality isn’t as pure in collaboration, but that being said, they work together in any effort to get a resolution.

Similarities Between Divorce Mediation and Collaborative Divorce

  1. Prevent Parties from Contested Divorce: Both mediation and collaborative divorce aim to prevent families from engaging in a heavily contested divorce process.

  2. Confidential: Both mediation and collaborative divorce are geared towards confidentiality, conversations, and having both parties reach a settlement or agreement.

  3. Both Help Negotiate Differences: In both divorce processes, there is an emphasis on negotiating differences, rather than sitting back waiting for a judge to make those decisions.

  4. Flexibility: These processes allow for flexibility in the divorce process, addressing emotional and financial issues, and working in the best interest of the family.

Collaborative Practice or Mediation in California Divorce? Which Path is Best for You in California?

Choosing between mediation and collaborative divorce can be decided mainly on how you want to approach problem-solving and how much professional help you need. Both have advantages and disadvantages, and here’s what you need to know:

Divorce mediation is recommended only when

Downsides of Mediation

Mediation is not recommended if one spouse is too dominant or refuses to provide relevant information. Mediation can also become ineffective if the emotional intensity is too great to render a productive discussion or negotiation. 

If mediation stalls, you are in a situation where you either have to return to court or find another way to get through your divorce.

Collaborative divorce is recommended only when

Downsides of Collaborative Divorce

Collaborative divorce can become expensive, depending on the number of professionals both spouses have on their team. If negotiations break down, they will need to hire new lawyers to go to court, which may complicate scheduling and/or cost more than they originally intended.

Divorce Smartly and Amicably in California— Mediate Your Divorce in the Cheapest Way Possible

Mediation and collaborative divorce share the same goals, but mediation is generally less expensive, faster, and more neutral. Collaborative divorce can feel more like litigation when lawyers are driving the process. 

Finding the best mediator is a good choice for couples who can be cooperative at a low-conflict level. Collaborative divorce works better for couples who have a higher level of conflict but need the structure and legal support of the collaborative process. Find the best option for you by booking a FREE DIVORCE CONSTULTATION with Dina Haddad, divorce mediator.

Frequently Asked Question: Divorce Mediation vs Collaborative Practice

“Better” depends on your needs. Collaborative divorce may be better for couples needing extra legal guidance or help managing complex finances. 

It provides structure and professional interaction that mediation may not offer, although collaborative divorce may take longer and cost more than mediation.

Collaborative divorce allows couples to negotiate out of court, and involves trained lawyers and other professionals to help settle their divorce. 

Traditional divorce typically involves formal filings and court appearances where a judge ultimately makes a final decision for couples who cannot agree with one another.

Looking For An Experienced Divorce Mediator?

Expert Californian Mediator Dina Haddad - Super lawyer

Dina Haddad, Esq.

Principal & Founder Attorney-Mediator

Dina Haddad is the founder and principal of Families First Mediation, one of California’s top-rated mediation services.